MFC Selection and Technical Guide: How to Choose Between an MFM and an MFC
In industrial gas measurement and precision gas delivery applications, thermal gas instruments are generally divided into two categories: Thermal Mass Flow Meters (MFM) and Mass Flow Controllers (MFC).
An MFM is designed to monitor gas flow in pipelines, while an MFC combines flow measurement with closed-loop flow regulation. Although both instruments rely on thermal dispersion sensing technology, their functions and application requirements are quite different.
Based on extensive field application experience, Aister Instrument explains their operating principles, technical advantages, and key selection criteria to help users choose the right instrument for their applications and evaluate cost-effective alternatives from Chinese manufacturers.
1. Working Principle of Thermal Mass Flow Measurement
Most thermal mass flow instruments operate based on the constant temperature difference (CTD) thermal dispersion principle.
The sensor typically contains two platinum resistance temperature detectors (RTDs). One is electrically heated, while the other measures the reference temperature of the gas.
As gas flows across the sensor surface, it carries away heat. The higher the gas mass flow rate, the greater the amount of heat removed.
The instrument maintains a constant temperature difference between the two sensors and calculates the gas mass flow rate based on the electrical power required to maintain this temperature difference.
This technology directly measures gas mass flow without requiring separate temperature and pressure compensation, and can provide standardized or mass flow readings depending on the instrument configuration.
The main difference between an MFM and an MFC is their functionality:
-
Thermal Mass Flow Meter (MFM): Measures and displays gas flow but does not have a built-in flow control valve. It is commonly used for industrial pipeline monitoring and energy consumption measurement.
-
Mass Flow Controller (MFC): Integrates a proportional control valve and electronic control circuit to automatically regulate gas flow through closed-loop feedback. It is mainly used in laboratories, gas mixing systems, and precision industrial processes.
2. Thermal Mass Flow Meter (MFM): Applications and Selection
Thermal mass flow meters are generally available in two configurations: inline and insertion types.
With turndown ratios ranging from 100:1 to 1000:1, depending on the model, and very low pressure loss, they are widely used for industrial gas measurement, particularly in compressed air and nitrogen pipelines.
Inline Thermal Mass Flow Meter
-
Typical pipe sizes: DN15–DN200
-
Provides high measurement accuracy.
-
Suitable for new installations and flow measurement in workshop branch pipelines.
Insertion Thermal Mass Flow Meter (ATMF Series)
-
Suitable for large pipelines ranging from DN65 to DN2000.
-
Supports hot tapping installation under suitable operating conditions, allowing installation without shutting down the gas supply.
-
An ideal option for energy-saving upgrades and flow measurement retrofits in existing industrial pipeline networks.
Key Selection Considerations
Before selecting an MFM, users should confirm the following parameters:
-
Pipeline diameter
-
Whether production shutdown is permitted during installation
-
Gas cleanliness and contamination levels
-
Operating temperature and pressure
-
Minimum, normal, and maximum flow rates
-
Communication interfaces
-
Required protection rating and explosion-proof certification
Important Installation and Maintenance Note
Thermal mass flow meters are sensitive to liquid water and heavy oil contamination. For applications involving oil mist or water droplets, an appropriate oil-water filtration system should be installed upstream to prevent sensor contamination and measurement drift.
Typical Applications
Thermal mass flow meters are commonly used for:
-
Compressed air energy consumption monitoring
-
Energy cost allocation between production workshops
-
Pipeline leakage detection
-
General industrial gas flow monitoring
They are not suitable for applications involving large amounts of liquid carryover or heavily dust-laden gases.
3. Mass Flow Controller (MFC): Working Principle and Technical Features
An MFC is a closed-loop flow control system consisting of three main components:
-
Thermal mass flow sensor
-
Proportional control valve
-
Electronic control circuit
It operates through a continuous cycle of measurement, comparison, adjustment, and stabilization.
The sensor continuously measures the actual gas flow rate and compares it with the user-defined setpoint. When a deviation occurs, the control circuit adjusts the valve opening in real time to bring the actual flow rate back to the target value.
This feedback process continuously compensates for disturbances. Depending on the model and operating conditions, the response time can be less than one second. Even when inlet pressure fluctuates within the specified operating range, the controller can maintain the target flow rate.
Key Advantages of MFCs
1. High Accuracy and Repeatability
Standard models typically offer accuracy of ±1.0% FS, while high-accuracy versions can achieve ±0.5% FS. Repeatability can reach ≤±0.2% FS, helping maintain consistent gas delivery in precision processes.
2. Direct Mass Flow Control
An MFC controls gas mass flow rather than relying solely on volumetric flow measurements. This makes it suitable for applications where temperature and pressure variations may otherwise affect volumetric flow readings, including chemical reactions and gas mixing processes.
3. Wide Turndown Ratio and Fast Response
With turndown ratios exceeding 100:1, MFCs can accommodate a wide range of gas flow requirements, from very small flow rates to higher flow rates, depending on the selected model.
4. Strong Automation Compatibility
MFCs support various communication and signal interfaces, including:
-
4–20 mA
-
0–5 VDC
-
RS485 Modbus
-
RJ45 digital interfaces
These options facilitate multi-device networking and integration with PLCs and supervisory control systems.
Aister AT010 Series Digital Mass Flow Controllers
The Aister AT010 Series Digital MFC uses a capillary thermal calorimetric measurement principle and features an SS316 stainless steel valve body.
Key features include:
-
Suitable for clean, dry gases and certain corrosive gas applications, subject to material compatibility.
-
Integrated laminar flow elements.
-
Multi-layer circuit board design for improved resistance to electrical interference.
-
One-touch zero calibration.
-
Flow range from 2 SCCM to 30 SLPM.
The AT010 Series provides a cost-effective alternative from a Chinese manufacturer for precision gas flow control applications.
Typical applications include:
-
Semiconductor manufacturing
-
Thin-film coating and deposition
-
Fuel cell testing
-
Laboratory gas mixing
-
Analytical instruments and testing equipment
4. MFM vs. MFC: Which One Should You Choose?
The choice between an MFM and an MFC depends primarily on whether your application requires flow monitoring or automatic flow regulation.
Choose a Thermal Mass Flow Meter (MFM), such as the Aister ATMF Series, if you need to:
-
Monitor gas flow in industrial pipelines.
-
Measure compressed air consumption.
-
Track energy usage and allocate operating costs.
-
Detect gas pipeline leakage.
-
Monitor general industrial gas processes.
Choose a Mass Flow Controller (MFC), such as the Aister AT010 Series, if you need to:
-
Automatically maintain a constant gas flow rate.
-
Control gas delivery in precision manufacturing processes.
-
Provide accurate gas mixing ratios.
-
Supply controlled gas flow to laboratory and testing equipment.
The key distinction is simple: an MFM measures gas flow, while an MFC measures and automatically controls it.
5. General Parameters to Consider When Selecting an MFM or MFC
Regardless of the instrument type, the following parameters should be confirmed before making a selection.
| Selection Parameter | Key Considerations |
|---|---|
| Gas Medium | Confirm the gas type, whether it contains oil or moisture, and whether it is corrosive. |
| Flow Rate | Specify the minimum, normal, and maximum required flow rates. |
| Operating Conditions | Confirm operating pressure and temperature. |
| Performance Requirements | Determine the required measurement accuracy and repeatability. |
| Electrical Interfaces | Select suitable analog or digital communication interfaces. |
| Protection Requirements | Confirm the required enclosure protection rating and explosion-proof requirements. |
Conclusion
Thermal Mass Flow Meters (MFM) and Mass Flow Controllers (MFC) share the same fundamental thermal dispersion measurement technology, but they serve different purposes.
An MFM focuses on industrial gas flow measurement, making it particularly suitable for compressed air energy monitoring, pipeline measurement, and industrial network upgrades.
An MFC combines flow measurement with closed-loop automatic regulation, making it the preferred solution for precision gas delivery, laboratory gas mixing, and automated industrial processes.
Understanding these functional differences and confirming the actual operating conditions are essential steps in selecting the right instrument.
Looking for a suitable thermal mass flow meter or mass flow controller for your application?
Contact Aister Instrument to discuss your gas type, required flow range, operating pressure, and control requirements. Our technical team can help you identify an appropriate MFM or MFC solution for your system.
- Why is the thermal gas mass flowmeter not affected by pressure strength and temperature?
- What to do when a thermal gas mass flow meter fails?
- How are thermal gas mass flow meters used? What are the applications?
- Under what circumstances is the gas measurement need to be regulated compensated vortex flowmeter
- Why Is The Aister Thermal Gas Mass Flowmeter So Popular ?
- Gas turbine flowmeter manufacturers explain their main advantages in measurement
- Gas turbine flowmeter manufacturer Aister instrument field experience summary
- Aister Instrument Empowerment Conference